Friday, October 18, 2013

Listening with our pens: Narrative humility for writers

I spend my life at the intersection of the stethoscope and the pen. Although I was originally trained in pediatrics and public health, as a writer, as well as a faculty member in Columbia University’s Master’s Program in Narrative Medicine, and co-chair of Columbia’s University Seminar on Narrative, Health and Social Justice, I spend most of my days writing, teaching, and thinking about the role of stories in healthcare.

Narrative Medicine is the clinical and scholarly endeavor to honor the role of story in the healing relationship. Long before doctors had anything of interest in their black bags – no MRIs, no lab tests, no fancy all body CAT scans – what they had was the ability to show up, what they had was the ability to listen, and bear witness to someone’s life, death, illness, suffering, and everything else that comes in between.

And so, I spend most of my days teaching clinicians-to-be how to listen. I do this by having them read stories, and take oral histories, and study lots of narrative theory. I teach them the work of scholars like medical sociologist Arthur Frank, who explains that when illness or trauma interrupt our life stories, we need new stories to help navigate these uncharted waters. Although it was always there, illness and trauma bring into sharp focus our basic human need for narration. We are, after all, fundamentally storied creatures.

But besides all this, what I also do is teach my students to listen by writing stories. I have them do listener response – writing in reaction to a poem or story we read in class. I have them write to a prompt – ‘when was the last time you witnessed suffering?’ I have them write ongoing personal illness narratives – weekly narratives in which I ask them to tell of the same experience but from a different point of view or genre or form to help unpack not only their own personal stories (stories which inform how they in turn will listen to the stories of others), but discover how stories work – in regard to plot, form, function, and voice.

So yes, I’m training people to be better doctors by teaching them how to be writers.

Over the years, I’ve explained some of how this all works with a philosophy of listening I’ve been callingNarrative Humility. Narrative Humility is not about gaining any sense of competence or mastery over our patients, or their stories. Rather, it is about paying attention to our own inner workings – our expectations, our prejudices, our own cadre of personal stories that impact how we react to the stories of others. You can hear me talk all about it here, during a recent TEDx event at Sarah Lawrence College (where I also teach).

But it serves to reason that if doctors can borrow skills from writers to do their jobs better, then perhaps the reciprocal thing can happen as well. In other words, does narrative humility have any lessons for those leading the writing life?

1.     Active Listening – This is an easy one. Writers are told all the time to listen: for regional accents, for scraps of interesting dialogue, for pieces of intriguing stories. We listen to ourselves too through journaling, going on writing retreats, and digging deep into our cadre of personal and familial stories for sources of inspiration. We even talk about listening to our characters, and letting them co-create the story that we’re telling. For writers, as for doctors, listening is a necessary adjunct to action. It is a way of filling ourselves up – like blood into the heart, air into the lungs – before we breathe out stories, images, words onto the page.

     To read the rest of this essay, please visit Uma Krishnaswami's Blog Writing with a Broken Tusk!


  1. I spend my life at the intersection of the stethoscope and the pen. Although I was originally trained in pediatrics and public health, as a writer,

    Buy Aicar
    CJC 1295 with DAC

  2. Narrative Medicine is the clinical and scholarly endeavor to honor the role of story in the healing relationship..............
    John Phanchalad at JP Digital Tech have a very good track record in digital media marketing. For more you can visit on

  3. Your dazzling work has won my heart. I’ll come soon to your site with new hope.
    mango exporter pakistan

  4. Thanks for sharing this post! Cheers regarding this kind of intriguing content the following. We seemed to be trying to find similar to in which pertaining to a reasonable time along with finally I've discovered the idea the following.
    Pinnacle Peptides

  5. Great points altogether, you just gained a brand new reader. What Pure Juvenate would you suggest in regards to your post that you made a few days ago?Marys small rant made sense to me, Jerry you really should respect her opinion and then maybe the respect will be returned to you. We are all from different backgrounds and circumstances.

  6. There is a wide diversity of opinions on the matter. You know what they gather. This is nuts. Crazy Bulk couldn't be more retarded if it had a helmet on it. Do you have a Fitness? That's inaccurate. I have a photograph of a Fitness somewhere.

  7. I don't have to leave you in the dark. Anti Aging is the creme de la creme. It really worked out when Skin Care substituted with Milou Skincare. As a master in that field, what I have is a desire related to Wrinkles. I was curious about that old Skin Care trick. From whence do teachers capture old Milou Skincare conferences? These are ground breaking reports.

  8. I believe Horlaxen is one of the most critical Male Enhancement things you can have. I mainly work with high impact Male Enhancement strategies. Male Enhancement could be a lot of fun. Male Enhancement has been above and beyond what I expected. There are a good number of other good reasons to do this. I wouldn't be without my Fitness. Horlaxen does not necessarily mean it was adapted to Fitness. Don't be afraid to be crazy. Some problems are effortless to solve.

  9. This time-lapse is, for example, similar to the recent Hillsborough disaster, amongst many other scandals that usually results in a time span sufficient to ensure that people or organisations responsible for the scandal no longer have to face the consequences of what they have done, Oral Jelly

  10. Aside from that, what are you going to make of Beauty Secret Answers? That is average sized.
    I had explored that I could not have more to say with regard to Beauty Secret Answers. I'm betting my wallet on it. That blog post will hopefully give you some opinions in that area. I imagine we all had an understanding of Beauty Secret Answers until now. There are a couple of differences this apply to Beauty Secret Answers yet you may not know the outcome. I believe this is the most salient part of using Beauty Secret Answers.

  11. Enzo Casino Reviews Italy La mia casa, non come un piano del casinò, ha solo alcune stanze e un piano terribilmente semplice da organizzare in modo da indurre intorno e lasciare quando mi piacerebbe. Se devo andare in un casinò, pagherò ore cercando di cercare la porta a causa di tutti i tavoli, le persone e i giochi che ospitano il suo piano.

    Visit Here :

  12. Crypto Soft Bewertung : Beachten Sie, dass trotz der tatsächlichen Tatsache gibt es derzeit Grundstücke in diesem leichtgläubigen Münzsammler Münzen, die Kupfer plattiert werden daher auf versuchen, diese Sorten von Cent zu machen sind geglaubt werden Bronze gekauft. Seien Sie vorsichtig, wenn jemand bietet Ihnen eine circa 1943 Cent aus einem metallischen Weißmetall konstruiert.Es gibt zusätzlich einen Lincoln Penny, der während 1972 freigegeben worden war, in dem das tatsächliche Datum zusammen mit den Buchstaben auf ihnen scheint, verdoppelt zu besitzen. Dies geschah nur, weil die Philadelphia Mint, der Ort, wo die Münze hergestellt wurde, versehentlich falsch ausgerichtet die Matrize für die Prägung der Münze verwendet.

    Visit cryptosoftbewertung

  13. Supreme Boostr It should be possible by stroking off alone or with the assistance of accomplice. The penis is animated and just before the inclination to discharge all sensations are ceased and after a large portion of a moment the procedure is to be rehashed.
    For More Details:-

  14. Supercharge Male Enhancement You can even accelerate the procedure by ensuring these biochemicals and supplements have greatest presentation to your penis through a light arrangement of penile activities that gets them into their objective are and keeps them there.
    For More Details:-

  15. Narrative Medicine is the clinical and scholarly endeavor to honor the role of story in the healing relationship. Long before doctors had anything of interest in their black bags – no MRIs, no lab tests, no fancy all body CAT scans – what they had was the ability to show up, what they had was the ability to listen, and bear witness to someone’s life, death, illness, suffering, and everything else that comes in between.

  16. Very informative and impressive post you have written, this is quite interesting and i have went through it completely, an upgraded information is shared, keep sharing such valuable information. Best pediatrics endocrinologist in the middle east

  17. Spot your shop is place where you will find all kind of facilities , but here you have to choose according to your own likelihood which field you want, and in front of you the list of all shops around you, will come in front of you and you can choose accordingly for exmp.- Home service, Travel, Properties & Rentals, Home Improvement, Job & Placement. sign in
    hotmail login


  18. ProMuscle Fit is a nutritional supplement that claims to use 4 different amino acids to increase lean muscle size and strength, boost energy, and more.
    Read More:


  19. xtrazex : Am încercat să se agită până regimul meu prin efectuarea unor yoga, kickboxing, sau de jo
    Confruntarea cu leziuni de la activităţi de fitness Accepţi dragostea pe care crezi că o meriţi. Dacă te simţi, da, nu mă deranjează pentru că nu cred că am făcut destul, atunci e un semn nesănătos.


  20. Extracto Esencial De CBD : Según la evaluación más reciente de la encuesta de Gallup, si resides en Estados Unidos, es mejor medir en Hawai, #one, no en West Virginia, #50. Por desGracia, la mayoría de los que viven en este último no tienen mucha selección-que necesitan para luchar río arriba hacia el bienestar, mientras que no es una marea ambiental muy favorable.

  21. Vital Keto : le plus sûr de tous les produits perte faisable sont des livres diététiques, surtout si vous venez de les lire. Les suivre ou s'abonner à ces idées ne sont peut-être pas la chose la plus simple du monde. Si vous souhaitez des programmes de régime et puis vous voudriez faire une paire de choses. Tout d'abord, passer à votre médecin pour un examen médical complet, et s'informer sur le type de régime que vous souhaitez aller en dessous.



  22. Idealica : Dopo la pulizia Detox è finita, il vostro corpo può essere puro come è mai stato e si può essere estremamente sensibile a ciò che vuole e sicuramente a ciò che non vuole. Ciò può facilitare il vostro alter la vostra dieta per mangiare soltanto gli alimenti che sono di destra per il vostro sistema del corpo.

  23. Vitality RX

    goes to the racks. Indeed here in Miracle Sex Diets is a critical

    subject. Engaging in sexual relations is great and it enhances

    wellbeing,it thins and it leaves more joyful and great specialist with

    life, does not it?

    Read More:

  24. 5G male is an

    execution enhancer for folks. The item incorporates a characteristic

    equation that blends assorted home-grown blooms which have been

    considered in clinical preliminaries and approved to expand certain

    variables that are related with a man’s typical real and sexual by and

    large execution.
    Read More:

  25. QualityHealthNow is the degree to which health care services for individual and populations growth the chance of preferred fitness outcomes..
    to keep the body in good health is a duty.otherwise we shall not be able to keep our mind strong and clear.
    Your Health Partner
    Products Categories:
    Read More: Health Now/

  26. Nice to be visiting your blog again, it has been months for me. Well this article that i’ve been waited for so long. I need this article to complete my assignment in the college, and it has same topic with your article. Thanks, great share :

    cara menyembuhkan radang usus secara alami
    cara mengobati nyeri dada secara alami
    obat jantung bengkak tradisional
    cara menghilangkan bekas luka menahun
    cara menyembuhkan parkinson secara alami
    cara mengobati sakit ulu hati sampai ke punggung
    cara menghilangkan mata ikan di telapak kaki

  27. The post is written in very a good manner and it contains many useful information for me. Thank you very useful information admin, and pardon me permission to share articles here may help :

    risa herbal
    cara menghilangkan benjolan
    toko obat herbal sapnudin
    sehat dan cantik alami
    khasiat obat herbal
    cara menghilangkan bekas jerawat

  28. Absolutely fantastic job you have done here.This is so nice.Thanks for sharing.
    clipping path

  29. Given article is very helpful and very useful for my admin, and pardon me permission to share articles here hopefully helped :

    Obat Gabagen Tradisional
    Obat Pendarahan Lambung Alami
    Cara Menghilangkan Darah Manis Secara Alami

  30. your post is so amazing and are always write your in the meaningful and explaining way.

  31. I turn to a vampire any time i want to. i become a vampire because of how people treat me, this world is a wicked world and not fair to any body. at the snack of my finger things are made happened. am now a powerful man and no one step on me without an apology goes free. i turn to human also at any time i want to. and am one of the most dreaded man in my country. i become a vampire through the help of my friend who introduce me into a vampire kingdom by given me their email. All thanks to Lord Shaka for your empowerment if you want to become a powerful vampire kindly contact the vampire kingdom on their Email: ( )

  32. It's very nice website. Everyone should visit here. Thanks for sharing and I found it very helpful. Don't miss WORLD'S BEST